K 00000001 A
Folklore and Superstition
For most of a century the two was the bill you did not want to be seen with. The stories are better than the evidence, and this page keeps them apart.
The Fed's Own Diagnosis
The one authoritative statement on the subject comes from the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, writing in 1976 about why the previous $2 had failed: "the limited quantity printed made the bill an extreme novelty, thereby contributing to public superstitions about it." Scarcity bred suspicion, suspicion bred hoarding, hoarding bred more scarcity. The 1976 relaunch was designed to break the loop with volume, which is why the plan called for "about 400 million $2 bills" a year.
Money magazine's history of the relaunch names the same problem on the ground: "superstitious gamblers considered them unlucky," cashiers "disliked them because cash trays lacked designated spaces," and the public "saw no practical value."
Sources: Richmond Fed, "The $2 Bill Returns," 1976 (PDF) · Money
The Four Legends
Coin-club histories and local news pieces tell the same four stories about how the two got its reputation. None of them comes with a document, and the Miami Valley Coin Club, whose write-up is the most careful, presents them as cultural belief rather than fact. Enjoy them on those terms.
The Devil's Deuce
"The $2 bill was often thought to be bad luck, as 'deuce' was a name for the devil." The cure was to tear off a corner, which was said to cancel the jinx. A note with all four corners torn was, by the logic of the legend, fully exorcised, and by the logic of the Treasury, mutilated currency headed for destruction. Which is one more reason so few old twos survive intact.
The Racetrack Window
Tracks took a standard $2 bet and paid winners in $2 bills. A wallet full of twos therefore announced that you had been at the track. Money's account of 1976 confirms the gambling link from the other direction: the bettors themselves thought the note unlucky.
The Two-Dollar Vote
"An urban legend claims that at one time, election rigging was common and the reward for a favorable vote was $2." Carrying one could look like evidence you had sold yours.
The Two-Dollar Trick
The story goes that in the 1920s a certain transaction cost two dollars, which gave the note an unprintable nickname and made it awkward to hand to a lady. It is the most repeated of the four legends and the least documented.
Source: Miami Valley Coin Club, "History of the Two-Dollar Bill: Are They Bad Luck?" Racetrack detail also in Money.
"Queer as a Two-Dollar Bill" Is the Wrong Bill
The saying people reach for when a $2 turns up is a corruption. The dictionaries and newspaper archives agree that the idiom was always the three-dollar bill, a note the federal government never issued (some state banks did in the 1800s). The etymologist Barry Popik's earliest print finds are a 1937 Brooklyn Daily Eagle ad, "Phoney as a Three Dollar Bill!!!", and "queer as a three-dollar bill" in a Texas paper on September 24, 1943, when "queer" still meant strange. Green's Dictionary of Slang dates the later sense to Donald Webster Cory's 1951 book The Homosexual in America ("as queer as a three-dollar bill"), with British cousins like "queer as a nine-bob note." No dictionary records the two-dollar version as original. So the $2 is real, legal, and, on the evidence, not the bill in the saying.
Sources: Barry Popik, "Phoney as a three-dollar bill" · Green's Dictionary of Slang, "queer as..." · Green's Dictionary of Slang, "phoney"
The Navy Payday Story
You will also hear that a Navy base once paid every sailor in $2 bills to show a hostile town how much of its economy came from the fleet. Norfolk, San Diego, Pensacola, and an Arkansas air base all get named. Nobody has produced a newspaper, a commander, or a date; when a Straight Dope thread asked for proof in 2014, none came. Employers have done exactly this, with sources, at Geneva Steel and Hornady. The military version stays in the folklore column until someone finds the clipping.
Where the Luck Turned
The same folklore that made the two unlucky in a card game made it lucky at the track, and in some communities it is simply lucky, full stop. The Federal Reserve's own currency education program says so: "During the Chinese Lunar New Year, it's tradition to give crisp $2 bills in red envelopes as a token of good luck." A Vietnamese community leader in Lancaster, Pennsylvania described the local custom as "a two dollar bill for the elderly and one dollar to children." Astronauts carried twos for luck too, all the way to the Moon. Clemson fans made the note a badge rather than a jinx. That story is next.
Sources: U.S. Currency Education Program, February 2024 · LNP / LancasterOnline, February 5, 2019 · Chase, "Lunar New Year: Red Envelope" · The $2 Bill in Space